We Booked the Wrong Catskills: Our Postcard Cabins Family Review
Our honest Postcard Cabins Western Catskills review: a booking mistake, helpful staff, a tiny cabin with kids, a waterfall hike, and Roscoe Beer Company.
Short answer: We would stay at Postcard Cabins Western Catskills again. The cabins were clean, the staff rescued us from our own booking mistake, and the weekend gave our kids exactly what they needed: a fire, a creek, a waterfall, and enough woods to disappear into without anyone asking for a screen.
But the trip almost did not happen that way.
The Mistake That Nearly Split Our Weekend
We planned a Catskills weekend with friends. They booked the Western Catskills. We somehow booked the Eastern Catskills.
That does not sound catastrophic until you realize the two properties are nowhere near close enough for a casual group weekend. By the time we caught the mistake, almost every cabin in the Western Catskills was sold out.
There was one cabin left for Friday night. We grabbed it and started doing the bad-trip math: stay with our friends Friday, drive an extra hour and a half on Saturday, switch locations, unpack twice, and spend half the weekend recovering from the logistics.
Then a Saturday cancellation opened up.
The Postcard Cabins team moved our reservation so we could stay in the Western Catskills both nights. We still had to switch cabins, and the second layout was different from the first, but both were spotless, comfortable, and ready when we arrived.
That one reservation change rescued the entire weekend.
The Cabin Is Tiny. That Is the Point.
Our cabin was named Cindy. The name on the door immediately made it feel less like a room assignment and more like our little corner of the woods.
Inside, the space was compact in the most literal sense. The bed, loft, kitchenette, storage, and everything we brought had to coexist. Once our bags were open and the snacks came out, it looked like a family had actually moved into a tiny cabin, because a family had.
It never felt dirty or neglected. It felt intentionally small. If you expect a normal Marriott hotel room with hallways, a lobby, and room to spread out, this is not that. The current Marriott property listing describes 36 tiny cabins across 70 wooded acres, each with a private bathroom, kitchenette, climate control, and its own outdoor area.
The funniest family touch was a set of bug catchers left in the cabin. Our kids spent more time safely catching and releasing insects than they would have spent with any toy we packed. That tiny detail understood the assignment better than a giant hotel game room ever could.
The Fire Pit and the S'mores That Ruined Regular S'mores
Every cabin has an outdoor area with Adirondack chairs and a fire pit. Ours sat under a thick canopy of trees, with enough seating for the adults and enough sticks, rocks, and dirt nearby to keep the kids occupied.
We have made a lot of campground s'mores. These were not normal campground s'mores.
The Postcard Cabins kit used better ingredients than the usual grocery-store emergency stack. It made roasting marshmallows feel like an actual event instead of dessert we were trying to finish before somebody dropped a flaming stick.
The kids loved it. The adults loved it. I am now annoyingly aware that better-quality ingredients really do make a better s'more.
If you want to recreate that kind of campfire dessert at home, Stroopies sells its own s'more kits with traditional Stroopies, chocolate, and marshmallows. This is not a sponsored or affiliate link—just a useful place to find them.
Our Best Catskills Day Required Almost Nothing
Saturday was the day that made the trip.
We took a short hike to a waterfall. The kids climbed rocks, stepped through the creek, tested every shallow pool, and turned a simple walk into more than an hour of exploring.
There was no elaborate activity plan. No timed ticket. No one was trying to squeeze in one more attraction before lunch. We just followed the water.
That was the reminder I needed: kids do not always need more entertainment. Sometimes they need shoes that can get wet and adults willing to stop watching the clock.
The waterfall itself was beautiful, but the creek was the real playground. Every bend created another place to climb, splash, or announce that a completely ordinary rock was now treasure.
If your family wants this kind of weekend, our family camping packing guide is a useful starting point even if you are sleeping in a climate-controlled cabin instead of a tent.
Three Hours at Roscoe Beer Company
After the hike, we went to Roscoe Beer Company. We expected to stop for a drink. We stayed almost three hours.
There was excellent local beer, a live band outside, lawn games, and enough space for the kids to run around and make friends while the adults relaxed. It worked as a brewery without treating families like an inconvenience.
Nobody checked the time. That is usually the best review I can give a place.
The Part of the Catskills Still Recovering
Recent heavy rain had left visible damage around the area during our visit. A Roscoe campground we tried to visit was temporarily closed while it recovered.
The towns still felt welcoming, local businesses were open, and spending the afternoon in Roscoe felt like a small, practical way to support a place getting back on its feet. Conditions can change quickly after storms, so check directly with campgrounds, trails, and local businesses before driving out.
What I Would Pack Next Time
The cabin is comfortable, but it still rewards a little planning.
Affiliate disclosure: Some Amazon links below are affiliate links, which means TripTiq may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. These are practical options to compare, not products supplied by Postcard Cabins.
- Groceries and simple meals. There is no restaurant on the property, and the fridge and cooking space are small.
- Downloaded directions and entertainment. Cell service and Wi-Fi can vary in the area.
- Creek shoes and a dry change of clothes. If your kids see water, they are going in the water. If you need trail shoes, Merrell Moab 3 hiking shoes are worth comparing with whatever broken-in pair your family already owns. Do not make a creek hike the first day anyone wears new shoes.
- Bug spray and a tick-check routine. This is real woodland, not landscaping around a hotel pool. Sawyer picaridin insect repellent spray is easier to pack than a bulky aerosol can.
- A headlamp and compact first-aid kit. Finding the cabin and managing the fire is easier before dark. This family camping essentials search covers both without turning the trip into a full camping-gear haul.
- One compact bag per person. Tiny-cabin floors disappear quickly under open luggage.
Would We Go Back?
Without hesitation.
What could have been a stressful weekend because of one booking mistake turned into one of our favorite family getaways of the summer.
The cabins were clean. The staff solved a real problem. The kids found adventure in bug catchers, creek water, and a campfire. We found a waterfall, a brewery we did not want to leave, and two evenings where nobody needed much more than a chair in the woods.
Sometimes the best trip story is not that everything went according to plan. It is that the right people and the right place kept one mistake from becoming the whole vacation.
TripTiq family rating: 5/5.
Kelly writes about family travel and packing at TripTiq Story. She has now added “confirm which side of the Catskills everyone booked” to the pre-trip checklist.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Postcard Cabins Western Catskills good for families?
It worked very well for our family because the cabin was clean, the outdoor space gave the kids room to explore, and small touches like bug catchers and the fire pit made the stay feel like an adventure.
What is inside a Postcard Cabin?
Cabins vary by layout, but the Western Catskills property lists beds, climate control, a private bathroom, kitchenette basics, linens, and an outdoor fire pit area. Check the current room description before booking.
Should I choose Eastern or Western Catskills?
Double-check the exact location before paying, especially if friends are booking separately. We accidentally booked Eastern Catskills while our group booked Western Catskills, and availability was nearly gone when we noticed.
Would we stay at Postcard Cabins Western Catskills again?
Yes. The staff helped rescue our reservation, both cabins were clean and comfortable, and the combination of outdoor time, nearby Roscoe, and relaxed evenings made it one of our favorite family weekends.
Related Guides
How to Hack a 3-Day Long Weekend with Kids (Without Burning PTO or Your Sanity)
The exact 5 hacks we use to stretch a 3-day family weekend without losing our sanity or overpacking. Featuring Ziploc outfit sets and sleep sanctuaries.
Family Camping Trip in Summer
Camping with kids made simple. Sleep, hydration, safety, and gear that actually stays organized.
Budget Travel Essentials Under $20
Pack smart for budget travel. Cheap packing gear that prevents expensive replacements on the road.
See the full packing list
We built complete packing lists for these trips — weather-aware, activity-matched, nothing forgotten.